Skip to main content

85. A New Translation of Canestrelli’s A Kootenai Grammar

Emma Halverson, Dr. Tim Thornes

Halverson final poster - view content on posts page
Select to view full poster image

Watch Intro Video

Abstract

Philip Canestrelli’s grammar of Kutenai (a language indigenous to northern Idaho), A Kootenai Grammar, was originally published in Latin in 1894. The grammar’s few English translations have not been linguistically informed, which has rendered the grammar, the earliest documentation of Kutenai, unavailable for revitalization efforts. To make Canestrelli’s work accessible to English speakers, I am referencing multiple editions of the grammar, a partial translation, and modern linguistic work on Kutenai to produce an English translation that is true to Canestrelli’s original meaning but still useful for modern linguists.

A Kootenai Grammar contains 144 pages. By May 2020 I will have completed translation of approximately 50 pages. I am supplementing the English translation with notes that compare Canestrelli’s analysis of Kutenai, which is based on Latin grammatical categories, to modern analyses of Kutenai. These annotations include notes on Canestrelli’s interpretation of various proximate and obviative morphemes—key features in the grammar of Kutenai. The translation and annotations I provide are equally informed by knowledge of Latin and modern linguistics so that A Kootenai Grammar, a key part of the documentation of the Kutenai language, is accessible in English.

Background

What is Kutenai?

The Kutenai language is the native language of the Kutenai people, and it is spoken in southeastern British Columbia, northwestern Montana, and northern Idaho, around the Columbia River Plateau. The language has a variety of names and spellings of those names, including Kutenai, Kootenai, Kootenay, Ktunaxa, and Ksanka.

Kutenai is a language isolate: it does not have a known historical or genealogical relationship to any other language. It is similar to other Native North American languages in that it is a polysynthetic language that allows complicated sentences to be expressed in one single, morphologically complex word.

Map Kutenai Area
A map of the Kutenai area, including British Columbia, Washington, Idaho, and Montana (Morgan, 1991, p. 2)

Who was Canestrelli?

Philip Canestrelli, S.J. Photo
A photograph of Philip Canestrelli, reproduced on the frontispiece of A Kootenai Grammar (1959).

Pater Philip Canestrelli, a Jesuit priest, was sent to St. Ignatius Mission in 1887, where he learned Kutenai and wrote a grammar titled Linguae Ksanka Elementa Grammaticae, known in English as A Kootenai Grammar. Canestrelli chose to write A Kootenai Grammar in Latin because the primary audience for the grammar was other Jesuit missionaries, who spoke different native languages but were familiar and comfortable with Latin. Latin was therefore the most accessible language for Canestrelli’s audience at the time.

Process

Methodology

Step 1: Translation.

I consider modern linguistic terminology and how it aligns with Canestrelli’s Latin. I use modern linguistic terms in translation whenever they closely align with or clarify Canestrelli’s meaning. For instance, Canestrelli refers to the object of a verb as a persona patiens, literally ‘patient,’ but ‘patient’ in modern linguistics denotes a receiver of an action whether or not the receiver is the grammatical object. Because Canestrelli uses persona patiens to refer only to grammatical objects of verbs, I translate it as ‘objects’ and not ‘patients’ to avoid confusion.

Step 2: Annotation.

I compare Canestrelli’s description of Kutenai to modern linguists’ analyses, and add annotations that explain major differences between perspectives. I also note places where Canestrelli’s Latin translations of Kutenai example phrases express shades of meaning that are not as apparent in the English translation.

Example Section

Original Text (Canestrelli, 1959, p. 16).

Original Text (Canestrelli, 1959, p. 16).

English Translation:

In the Kutenai language, the subject of a verb is distinguished from the same verb’s object through a twofold form that the noun can assume, either ordinary or secondary, (Annotation Note 1) so that the ordinary form in Kutenai applies the same as the nominative case in Latin and the secondary form applies the same as the accusative or ablative. (Annotation Note 2)

Annotations

  1. i.e., the proximate (“ordinary”) and obviative (“secondary”).
  2. Because of his strong Latin background, Canestrelli equates the proximate and obviative to Latin case marking, even though Kutenai does not use a case marking system. The proximate form specifies the most topical participant of a clause, and the obviative occurs on the clause’s less topical participants.

Languages

Four languages are involved in translation: Kutenai, Latin, English, and Italian. When Canestrelli provides an example Kutenai sentence, he gives a Latin translation and, infrequently, an Italian translation. Below, Canestrelli shows how the Kutenai definite article na is used when a speaker lists items. Because Latin has no definite article to fully illustrate the principle, he gives both Latin and Italian translations (Canestrelli, 1959, p.14). The English is my resulting translation.

  • Kutenai: na gapi, na k’kikul, na akulak, kapi sukni
  • Latin: bulbi, panis, caro, omnia sunt bona
  • Italian: la gamasce, il pane, la carne, sono tutte cose buone
  • English: the onions, the bread, the meat, all are good

Further Plans

As of April 10, 2020, I have translated and annotated approximately 30 pages of A Kootenai Grammar. I will continue with translation and annotation, with the short-term goal of completing 50 pages by May and the long-term goal of producing a translation of the full book.

Acknowledgements

I wish to thank Dr. Matthew Dryer and Dr. Sarah Thomason for providing materials on Kutenai, and Karen Wadley for assisting with Latin translation.

References

  • Anon. (1988). Grammar of the Kutenai Language [Unpublished translation.]
  • Canestrelli, P. (1959). A Kootenai Grammar. Spokane, WA: Gonzaga
    University.
  • Canestrelli, P. (1927). Grammar of the Kutenai Language. International Journal of American Linguistics, 4(1), 1-84.
  • Mast, S. J. (1983). Aspects of Kutenai Morphology [Master’s thesis, University of Pittsburgh].
  • Morgan, L. W. (1991). A Description of the Kutenai Language [Doctoral dissertation, University of California, Berkeley].

Additional Information

For questions or comments about this research, contact Emma Halverson at emmahalverson@u.boisestate.edu.