Beginning in 1986, ASBSU honored exceptional athletes with a spot in the Hall of Fame for Varsity Athletics.
| 2004 | (none) |
| 2003 | Greg Sasser |
| 2002 | (none) |
| 2001 | Jessica Riehle |
| 2000 | Rashid Gayle |
| 1999 | Brandy Mamizuka |
| 1998 | (none) |
| 1997 | Julie Wagner |
| 1996 | Leslie Mott |
| 1995 | Remy Pop |
| 1994 | Robyn Ranells |
| 1993 | Ann Tibbetts |
| 1992 | Anne Staker |
| 1991 | Kristine Littlefield, Kathy Karpel |
| 1990 | Lee Galway, David Lowery |
| 1989 | Jan Ecklund |
| 1988 | Carmel Major, Jeff Foster |
| 1987 | (none) |
| 1986 | Janet M. Woolum, Lind A. Clemens |
Compiled by Rachel Taylor, Summer 2019 intern