The Religious Organization of the Year Award was given to one religious club every year starting in 1986 to recognize their outstanding work.
| 2002 | Women’s Institute Association |
| 2001 | St. Paul’s Catholic Student Group |
| 2000 | Latter-Day Saint Student Association |
| 1999 | Latter-Day Saint Student Association |
| 1998 | Latter-Day Saint Student Association |
| 1995 | St. Paul’s Catholic Student Group |
| 1994 | Latter-Day Saint Student Association |
| 1993 | St. Paul’s Catholic Student Group |
| 1992 | United Methodist Student Movement |
| 1991 | United Methodist Movement |
| 1990 | Baptist Campus Ministries |
| 1986 | (no entries submitted) |
Compiled by Rachel Taylor, Summer 2019 intern